• Home
  • About
    • About Christopher di Armani
    • Disclosure Statement
    • Code of Ethics
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Gun Laws 101
  • FPO Violators
  • Store
  • Donate
  • Hire Me

Christopher di Armani.com

In Praise of Individual Rights and Freedoms

  • Top 25
  • Big Brother
    • Access To Information
    • Bureaucratic Incompetence
    • Bureaucrat’s Rule #1
    • Censorship
    • Feeding at the Government Trough
    • Lemonade Freedom
  • Common Sense
    • Expressions of Gratitude
    • Good Samaritans
    • Good Stuff
    • In Memoriam — Remembering our Heros
    • Life
    • Personal Responsibility
    • Politically Correct Madness
  • Courts
    • Abusive Prosecutions
    • Civil Forfeiture
    • Human Rights Tribunals
    • Judicial Corruption
    • Justice Denied
    • Justice System Abuses
    • Police Sentencing Double-Standards
    • Prosecutorial Misconduct
    • SLAPP Lawsuits
  • Crime
    • Abuse of Trust
    • Canadian Mass Murders
    • Firearm Prohibition Orders
    • Human Depravity
    • Immigration Issues
    • Racism
    • Restraining Orders
    • Sexual Predators
    • Violent Criminals
    • Wrongful Convictions
  • Guns
    • Concealed Carry
    • Dial 9-1-1 and Die
    • Firearms Act
    • Fun Gun Stuff
    • Gun Control
    • Gun-Free Zones
    • Gun Politics
    • Gun Registration
    • Negligent Discharges
    • Target Shooting Competitions
  • Islam
    • Canadian Islamic Disgraces
    • Islamic Terrorism
    • Radical Islam
    • Sharia Law
    • The Religion Of Peace
  • Police
    • Abuse of Police Authority
    • Filming Police
    • Great Police Officers
    • Officer Down
    • Police Brutality
    • Police Corruption
    • Police Misconduct
    • RCMP Accountability
    • RCMP Hall of Shame
    • Warrantless Searches
  • Politics
    • Elections
    • Ethics in Politics
    • Political Antics
    • Political Corruption
    • Social Justice
    • Stupid Human Tricks
    • Union Bay Improvement District
  • Rights
    • Charter of Rights and Freedoms
    • Constitutional Violations
    • Freedom of Assembly
    • Freedom of Religion
    • Freedom of Speech
    • Property Rights
    • Privacy Rights
    • Self-Defense
    • Unreasonable Search and Seizure

Vaccination Status None of Court’s Business says BC Justice Geoffrey Gomery

Published August 12, 2021 by Christopher di Armani Filed Under: Privacy Rights


On August 8, 2021, BC Supreme Court Justice Geoffrey B. Gomery slammed the door on violating an individual’s right to medical privacy.

“There is no good reason to ask the question and I therefore declined to put it to panellists,” Justice Gomery ruled.

A Crown prosecutor wanted Justice Gomery to exclude any potential jurors who were not vaccinated or who refused to allow the Crown to violate their right to privacy.

From the decision:

Objectively, the risk to jurors, if some of them are unvaccinated is very low.  If panellists had expressed concerns about Covid exposure, I would have excused them in any event.

The proposed question as to vaccination status trenches on a private and personal sphere.  Panellists might well have reasons to wish not to discuss their vaccination status in public in the intimidating environment of a courtroom.  Some might be intimidated by the question itself.  Offering an assurance that they need not reply would mitigate, but not eliminate, the pressure.

This is not in itself a reason not to put the question – participants in the justice system are sometimes required to disclose personal and private information in open court – but the question is one that should only be required if circumstances demand it.

I am not persuaded that the question would provide information that I could properly make use of in deciding whether to stand aside or excuse a juror.  The power to stand aside a juror is granted under s. 633 of the Code “for reasons of personal hardship, maintaining public confidence in the administration of justice or any other reasonable cause”.

The participation of an unvaccinated juror – or one who will not say that he or she has been fully vaccinated – does not engage a question of personal hardship of the juror in question.  Given our experience to date of jury trials with unvaccinated jurors, as I have described, I do not think the participation of unvaccinated jurors risks public confidence in the administration of justice.  Nor am I persuaded that a failure to provide an assurance of fully vaccinated status constitutes “other reasonable cause”, at least at this time under the health and social conditions now prevailing.

The BC Civil Liberties Association’s Privacy Handbook says:

Although the Charter does not contain the word “privacy”, and does not include a freestanding “right to privacy,” privacy interests have been recognized to be at the root of some of the protections granted by the Charter.

The Supreme Court of Canada has decided that the source of the section 8 right is that citizens have a reasonable expectation of privacy in a free and democratic society.

The liberty right in section 7 protects an individual’s privacy when making the kinds of fundamental life choices which are at the core of individual dignity and independence, so that they can be made without interference from the state.

The right to privacy and to maintain the privacy of information about ourselves has been recognized as an essential aspect of liberty in a free and democratic society.

Justice Gomery’s ruling in favour of our right to privacy is extremely promising in an age where courts routinely rule COVID-19 trumps our rights in almost every other area of life.

Now, if we can just find a judge, anywhere in Canada, willing to rule in favour of our Charter Section 2 right to freedom of expression and our right to freedom of religion, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms might actually be worth the paper it’s printed on.

Author

  • Christopher di Armani
    Christopher di Armani

    Christopher di Armani is a freedom-loving Amazon bestselling author and current events commentator from Lytton, BC, Canada, who strives to awaken the passion for liberty inside every human being.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Tags: BC Supreme Court, freedom of religion, Justice Geoffrey B. Gomery, privacy rights, right to freedom of expression, vaccination status

Did you find value in this article?

If you found this article useful or it contained valuable information and you want to thank me, the best way is to buy me a coffee or two.

1. Send an Interac eTransfer to author @ christopherdiarmani.net (remove spaces)

2. Send via PayPal using this link: https://www.paypal.me/ThatLibertyGuy

3. Use your credit card in my online store to support me with a one-time donation, a monthly recurring donation, or an annual donation. See these links for all the details about the thank-you gifts I offer my supporters.

Comments

  1. Lynn Cournoyer says

    August 13, 2021 at 7:15 am

    Finally someone reasonable in the world of justice and our rights. It is no ones business if you are vaccinated or not. Hats off to Justice Gomery.

    Reply
  2. Joe says

    August 13, 2021 at 11:38 am

    Excellent ruling. Unfortunately I have no faith that other judges will abide by this precedent, and will likely say some “think of the children” or “of it saves one life” BS to justify ignoring it. I am in on any class action lawsuit regarding vax passports.

    Reply
  3. peter bolten says

    August 14, 2021 at 5:11 pm

    Two days ago Bonnie Henry and the Health Minister’s office announce that all health care workers MUST take two doses of the vaccine before oct 12th 2021, or else….meaning job loss. There is no mention n of exemptions for medical reasons, of which many people have had reactions after faithfully putting out their arms for the first jab. And trying to document these with their G.P.
    And no apparent medical follow-up and studies of these people that had adverse reactions.
    Then there are those for whatever reason did not go for any vaccination.
    Unions and employers are quoting ” you agreed to the collective contract” , “majority opinion rules” [ shaming in reality], ” a very high bar for exemptions “,excuses for not allowing these workers to give consent or allow autonomy of body.
    Trudeau’s core of ministers also wish to similarly mandate this upon over 500,000 federal workers.
    I am hearing open talk of Trudeau being a communist.
    Of my multipoint concern here is another biggy: when many of these people are fired, jobless as a result of not complying, they will be facing difficult hardship , notwithstanding other stressors in life such as housing/rent issues and relationship issues and family and financial issues… there will be a surge , an epidemic of suicides and self-harm and crisis-line overloads.
    Trudeau/Blair, Freeland/ Lametti talks the talk of women’s rights and suicide=prevention, and yet this action and BC’s actions will propel many people down this irreversible path.

    Reply
    • Christopher di Armani says

      August 14, 2021 at 7:01 pm

      A good friend of mine is in this exact spot, Peter. She must either get the jab – which she is totally opposed to – or lose the career she’s built over the past 10 years because of some arbitrary government edict. She is distraught, as you can imagine, at being forced into making a decision no human being should ever face: accept forced medical treatment in violation of her Charter rights or lose her job. Because nobody is willing to stand up to COVID and defend Charter rights. It’s sickening.

      Reply
  4. Steve Barragan says

    August 15, 2021 at 2:25 pm

    Sure hope more Judges rule in favour of freedom like this Judge has. I’m really concerned and have actually lost sleep about the latest announcement by the minister of transport. I cannot in good conscience before God take the vaccines due to them being abortion tainted and I am a Christian. The reality is that I may lose my job as a result of this draconian measure. I find it interesting how Liberals are all for “My body, My Choice” when it comes to abortions but when it comes to a personal decision about a vaccine they say and do the complete opposite. Sometimes I wonder how far will this nonsense go?

    Reply
    • Christopher di Armani says

      August 15, 2021 at 9:48 pm

      I suspect we will find out exactly how far this nonsense will go on September 21st – the day after the federal election.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to my commentaries

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Latest Tweets

Follow @ThatLibertyGuy

Christopher di Armani 🇨🇦 🇺🇸
@ThatLibertyGuy

  • New comment: Edmonton Police Service Constable Adam Kube Refused Any Appeal In His Termination for Corrupt Practices christopherdiarmani.com/10846/police/p…
    about 3 weeks ago
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • A big shout out to @CandiceMalcolm, @AndrewLawton, @AnthonyFurey and the entire team at @TrueNorthCentre for sendin… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
    about 4 weeks ago
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • For earthly princes lay aside their power when they rise up against God, and are unworthy to be reckoned among the… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
    about 1 month ago
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • New comment: Paul Rogan Passes: The End of an Era christopherdiarmani.com/18908/common-s…
    about 2 months ago
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • To restore common sense to our nation, this is the path. The political left works around the clock and around the… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
    about 2 months ago
    Reply Retweet Favorite

Most Popular This Week

  • All that is required for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing
  • No Right to Bear Arms in Canada? You might want to re-check your history.
  • A Historic Day for Freedom of Speech: Geert Wilders
  • The National Anthem BANNED… at Indiana’s Goshen College?
  • Thank God for Andrew Abbass and his Lawyer
  • Paul Palango: One Man’s Pursuit of the Truth Could be the RCMP’s Undoing
  • Yvon Mercier: From RCMP Depot Trainer to Double-Murderer

Most Popular This Month

  • All that is required for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing
  • Yvon Mercier: From RCMP Depot Trainer to Double-Murderer
  • OPP Sgt. Mike Dolderman’s Sexual Assault Trial Delayed Again
  • How did Live-Streaming Rape Become a ‘Thing’?
  • Dale Merle Nelson’s 1970 Murder Spree in Creston, British Columbia
  • OPP Sergeant Jamie Gillespie Pleads Guilty to attempting to intercept private communications
  • Escaped Mental Patient William Bernard Lepine and the 1972 Kettle Valley Murders

© 2004–2023 ChristopherDiArmani.com | All Rights Reserved

Close

Buy me a cup of coffee

A ridiculous amount of coffee was consumed in the process of writing these articles. If you enjoy my work, please buy me a coffee or two to keep me going!